— Compare

Managed IT vs break-fix support.

There are two ways to buy IT support. With break-fix, you call someone when something breaks and pay for that visit. With a managed IT agreement, you pay a fixed monthly fee and a provider looks after the computers, accounts, backups, and security all the time. Break-fix is not a mistake for every business, and a managed agreement is not always worth its fee. The right choice depends on how many people you have, what an hour of downtime costs you, and what data you hold.

— The options, side by side

Managed IT vs break-fix support — The options, side by side
Criterion Managed IT agreementBreak-fix support
Best for Businesses with several staff who rely on their computers all day, hold client or patient data, and need a predictable IT bill.Very small offices with a few standard computers, little sensitive data, and someone on staff who handles the basics.
Where it wins
  • A fixed monthly cost you can budget for, with no surprise invoice after a bad month.
  • Patching, backups, and monitoring happen on a schedule, so many problems are caught before staff notice them.
  • The provider already knows your setup, so a fix starts with the problem, not with learning your network.
  • The provider earns the same fee whether you have ten tickets or none, so preventing problems is in their interest.
  • Security basics such as multi-factor sign-in, device management, and tested backups are part of the service, with someone accountable for them.
  • No monthly commitment. You pay only when you need help.
  • In a quiet year, it costs less than any managed agreement.
  • Simple to start and simple to stop, with no contract and no onboarding.
  • It suits one-off jobs well: a new printer, a single laptop repair, a small office move.
Where it costs you
  • You pay every month, including the months when nothing goes wrong.
  • For a very small or very simple setup, the fee can be more than break-fix would have cost that year.
  • Agreements differ a great deal. Projects, on-site visits, and hardware are often outside the monthly fee, and you have to read the scope.
  • A provider with a long contract and a vague service level can coast. The agreement is only as good as its written terms.
  • Onboarding takes real effort from you: an inventory, access to every account, and some changes to how staff work.
  • Nobody is watching between incidents. Updates, backups, and security settings are your job, and in practice they often go undone.
  • The technician is paid when things break, so there is no built-in reason to prevent the next failure.
  • Costs are unpredictable. A ransomware incident or a dead server produces a large bill with no warning.
  • Each call starts from scratch, because nobody keeps documentation of your systems.
  • You wait in line behind other customers, with no agreed response time.
  • A backup that nobody tests is often found to be broken on the day it is needed.

— How to decide

Read down the list and stop at the line that sounds like you.

  • An hour without email or files stops the whole team from working. Points to Managed IT agreement
  • You have two or three computers, standard software, and a staff member who is comfortable with the basics. Points to Break-fix support
  • You hold client, patient, or financial records, or an insurer or client has asked about your security. Points to Managed IT agreement
  • Nobody can say for certain when the backups were last tested. Points to Managed IT agreement
  • You need help a few times a year, and a day of waiting would not hurt. Points to Break-fix support
  • The owner has become the IT person and wants that time back. Points to Managed IT agreement
  • IT invoices swing widely from month to month and you cannot budget for them. Points to Managed IT agreement

— Where SetKernel fits

  • We work under managed agreements

    SetKernel looks after the businesses it manages: the scope is written down, it runs month to month, and that is what lets us know your environment before something breaks. You write a short brief and we answer in writing with a fixed price before anything starts.

  • We are the wrong choice for a one-off repair

    We do not do one-off break-fix for businesses we do not manage. If you have three computers, no sensitive data, and need a laptop fixed twice a year, a good local technician is the right call and costs you less than we would. We would sooner say that than sell you a monthly fee you do not need.

  • Fixed-scope projects sit in between

    A migration, a security clean-up, or a server build can be a one-time project at a fixed price for a defined scope, without a monthly agreement. It is a sensible first step if you are unsure about ongoing management and want to see how we work.

Common questions

Is managed IT more expensive than break-fix?

In a quiet year, yes. Over several years, including the cost of downtime and of one serious incident, it is often less. The honest comparison is your last two or three years of IT invoices and lost working hours against a written managed quote.

What does a managed IT agreement usually include?

Typically monitoring, patching, helpdesk for staff, security tooling, backup checks, and periodic reviews. On-site visits, hardware, and large projects are often billed separately. Ask for the scope in writing, with a named response time.

At what size does managed IT start to make sense?

There is no fixed number. It tends to make sense once several people depend on shared systems all day, or as soon as you hold data that would be costly to lose or leak. A two-person office with standard laptops can often stay on break-fix.

Can I keep break-fix and still be secure?

Only if someone on your side reliably does the work in between: updates, multi-factor sign-in, backups, and restore tests. Break-fix does not include that by default. If nobody owns it, that gap is where incidents tend to begin.

Can I switch from break-fix to managed IT without disruption?

Yes. A managed provider starts with an inventory and takes over in stages, usually without interrupting staff. Expect to hand over admin access and passwords, which is a good moment to find out who actually holds them today.

— Tell us what you need

Not sure which way to go?

Tell us the problem in two paragraphs — what you run, what is getting in the way, what done looks like. We will tell you honestly which option fits, even when it is not us. We reply in writing within one business day.